Good Service Means Successful Transit
Brampton, Ont. has discovered the key to a successful transit system.
Run buses more frequently and provide good service.
Who knew?
—
What this place shows, though, is that even in a place without any of the supposed prerequisites, you can still get tens of thousands of people to choose to ride the bus. We don’t have to wait until all our suburbs are rebuilt to become European-style walkable utopias; it’s possible to get people out of their cars in a matter of months simply by running buses more frequently.
—
To read this story from Bloomberg CityLab, click here.
What we did in Ottawa is we provided bad unreliable bus and train service and, when that didn’t work and OC Transpo ran up huge deficits, we cut back service through New Ways to Bus. So bad service became appalling service.
Here is something basic to so many things.
Provide a good service that people need and they will buy it.
Provide a bad service that people need and they will find alternatives to the bad service to satisfy their needs.
The alternative to bad transit service in Ottawa is old beater cars. Accordingly, more traffic (hindering bus scheduling) and more pollution. Transit is supposed to be climate-friendly but in Ottawa, it is not.
Then we buy electric buses that will be charged by huge natural-gas generators.
That is politics over reality. We tell people we’re going green with electric buses but in fact they are being charged with natural gas. Where is the climate benefit of that?
Electric buses are more expensive than their diesel counterparts but with less range and worse reliability, particularly in cold climates.
Sheer trickery, bad politics and terrible public policy.
Ken Gray
For You:
Gov’t Raises Housing Obstacles: BENN
Ask Developers What Housing In Demand: BENN
The Day After The Lansdowne Vote: POTTER
City Backs Millionaires But Not You: PATTON
Reject Builder Breaks In Housing Initiative: LEIPER
Bookmark The Bulldog, click here
I gotta finally say, Ken, that your electric bus thing is silly. Buying gas generators as a transition and a backup makes total sense. There was never a plan to charge the buses from gas generators for any great period of time but only while the grid capacity got extended to where it was needed and if and when the grid had a hickup. Transition and backup, that’s it. Otherwise they charge off the grid.
Thanks for bringing our attention to the article about transit in Brampton. Providing service is how you get riders!
I cannot resist adding that all those “zum” buses in Brampton have notices on the rear flank indicating that they stop at all level rail crossings. Unlike OC Transpo, which is magically protected from deadly interactions with trains, the buses in Brampton avoid playing chicken with trains and nonetheless seem to attract passengers.
Jake:
I gotta finally say that I’ve got a hectare or two of swamp land in Florida for you. Great price.
You don’t buy two generators the size of which can light a city of Brockville for a backup or transition.
That’s a hell of a back up Jake. Maybe Hydro is running out of capacity, my friend.
cheers
kgray
How long will this transition from natural gas generators to grid take? Related question: why should we believe the city on any timeline they talk about?
How much will this grid upgrade cost? Is it part of the Alan Hubley ‘free money’, the loan that has to be repaid from future operating budgets? Related question: why should we believe the city regarding anything involving on budget, let alone on time?
What areas in the Hydro Ottawa service areas will forego upgrades to just adequate service due to the diversion of resources to upgrade the grid?
Will the resources directed at upgrading the grid be diverted from the climate change resiliency program that Hydro Ottawa has talked about during the last couple of years?
Standard Operating Protocol for city council and staff: big on promises, short on details. Not to worry though. They tell us we should trust them and then whine about why we don’t.
Ken,
I don’t know why you’d think that, say, 350 electric buses wouldn’t need generators the size that could power Brockville (previously) to cover their charging needs for backup. It seems reasonable to me. I’ve asked some experts for the numbers. I’ll get back to you.
You seem to be saying that the SIZE of the generators somehow equates to they being the only source of power for the buses. Electricity from the grid would be far cheaper.
Is your view of OC Transpo so jaundiced that you don’t think they would make the economical choice?
And, no, I’m not taking swampland in Florida any more. In case you haven’t heard, there’s a very hostile regime in charge there now. I’m looking at James Bay for swampland. Wanta join me?
Jake
Jake:
Hydro Ottawa doesn’t have the capacity there.
cheers
kgray